luke robinson or danny brough

who would you rather see playing the scrum half role at the giants,

Robbo or Brough
i think Brough is a lazy player, noticed this when we played them at home, as Robbo never seems to stop running,
? ? ?

I would have to say that skills wise Brough beats robbo hands down particularly in respect of kicking and organising.
They are however completely different plyers and Robbo is a dynamo who gives us a lot of options in respect of his running at players or going through the gaps ala Burrows.
There is however the problem of Broughs attitude and it would be a question of whether Brown could tame him.

For me it is not who is the best but how do they complement their potential halfback partner. For me i could see them playing together with Brough at 6.

Personally I would prefer Brough with Robinson replacing Moore,also I'm not convinced Faiumu will be here next season, I just think Brough has some good sides to his game, He has one of the best passes I've ever seen, he has a good kicking game, lots of pace and is one of the best goal kickers in the game. I dont know anything about his attitude but it seems to get mentioned a lot, I know that by glancing at the Wakey board, almost to a person they are desperate to keep him so he must have something, I would be happy to see him here ,I think he would bring a lot to the team, A SO for me is the big need and failing a new quality player, i would be tempted to play Hodgson there with Cudjo in his proper place, and try for someone like Brougton, Does any of this make sense to anyone else, or am i just losing the plot,It's all good fun speculating.

Forget Brough he wont be coming he has signed for HKR.

Old School wrote:

Forget Brough he wont be coming he has signed for HKR.

Thats a shame.

Someone at Wakey once said to me that Brough has lost as many games as he has won.

That i think is his problem. Some days he is amazing others he isn't.

Old School wrote:

Forget Brough he wont be coming he has signed for HKR.

Hmmm i remember someone once telling me that he was coming to us and i could take that to the bank

So if he has signed for HKR lets start this thread again.

Who would you like to see playing scrum half for the Giants next year Robbo or Dobson

i think we should keep Robbo, he is a good player, and there isnt many games where he doesnt give 100%

wheatley92 wrote:

i think we should keep Robbo, he is a good player, and there isnt many games where he doesnt give 100%

Totally agree! Robbo always works his socks off week in week out. Great to watch when he is at his best.

Yep, Luke has come on in leaps and bounds, I can only see him getting better.

Personally I'd give him another season and sign a world class SO.

after watching brough last night against saints i hope we get him

only sean long is a better british half in super league

defleppard wrote:

after watching brough last night against saints i hope we get him

only sean long is a better british half in super league

Well Robinson had a wonderful game today, can we accommodate both?

Robinson was awesome in the first half. Didn't notice him as much in the second though. I think Robinson showed today that he's come on leaps and bounds since last season.

He was superb today. Like a little terrier!

Looking at the Warrington game it would have to be Robbo everytime.

He was like a little general probing and whizzing about the field.

His kicking was much better trying little chips over ect.

Lets hope he keeps it up until end of season now and we have a really good chance of some silverware.

Definately Robbo ! hes tough to handle and has so much passion was speaking to him after the game he was so pleased with the win. He brings a lot to the team ...