Scott Moore

Out of contract at end of season, should we try and keep him? how many 9s do we need.
l think Fiamu good player but will not get another contract. Quota place
Lunt, has plenty of time in the bank, should improve
Fulton, Browns choice, has to deliver
Moore ?
thoughts,,,

He works really hard, a very busy player, but for someone who is so heavily involved, he doesn't seem to have the spark to create and worry teams. Basically good, but not in Drew's league. For that reason I wouldn't be too bothered either way.

If Moore carries on as he has done then yes we should try our best to keep him. I like Faiumu but as you say, Lunt looks a good prospect and has plenty of time on his side. So for next season if we can sign Moore then i'd let Faiumu go and keep Lunt and Moore as our first choice hookers.

I would really like us to keep him but I fel we have no chance. Saints are very canny and he has a year to run with them after this year. They are doing the same with Smith. I think if Moore carries on the way he has been this season, he will find himself back at Saints.

I am not impressed with Faiumu at all. Would not be fussed if he goes at the end of the season, he is just not very noticable in a game and I do not think he can compete with the class we now have for a backrow spot. Hope he can prove me wron g mind for the rest of the season. Would like nothing more than some test form from him like he has clearly produced in the past!

Think Faiumu's trouble is that he hasn't had much game time. He posesses a wicked side step and can through out some superb passes. But so far this season we haven't seen much of him. I don't know if this is due to being overlooked or because of little injuries.

when l say he´s out of contract, l mean with Saints so he will be a free agent, so if he´s open to offers, the decision will probably be Browns, but with Brown, bringing in Fulton, he looks favorite.

boomer wrote:

when l say he´s out of contract, l mean with Saints so he will be a free agent, so if he´s open to offers, the decision will probably be Browns, but with Brown, bringing in Fulton, he looks favorite.

I would be happy to keep Moore, Faiumu has his good points but as yet has not showed up enough, with Fulton as well we are over booked, end of day NB will decide.

Mick Potter was at the Quins game. Suspect he was watching Moore's progress with us.

I would plan ahead without him, because if Saints want him back at the end of the season, we would not be caught out if he went.
He is playing well at present, but before he came to us I thought he was nothing special.
So is he just pulling out all the stops so Saints will take him on ? . And if they don`t will he just slip back to his Cas days just average.

I think the Giants will be prepared to lose Moore next season as it seems we've signed Nathan Fein for next year.

dont forget about keal carlile,i think the kid has a big part to play for the giants,along with lunt
dont right off faiumu yet,give the lad a chance,he as been injured and had to deal with a family bereavement.
he will come good

Watching Moore on Friday was like waching Cunningham. He was, to me, extremely impressive.

Mind you, I also like the look of Lunt. He impressed me more than Moore at the start of the season.

Faiumu's lack of game-time has meant that he has yet to show us his best.

Helen wrote:

Watching Moore on Friday was like waching Cunningham. He was, to me, extremely impressive.

Mind you, I also like the look of Lunt. He impressed me more than Moore at the start of the season.

Faiumu's lack of game-time has meant that he has yet to show us his best.

I also have been impressed with Lunt, right from the pre-season game at Fax I think it was, He reminds me of a player who was at Keithley a few years ago when they were a decent side, and then later at Widnes, can't remember his name, but i think he started at Wigan, I know he had some good games against us, Anyway that's who he reminds me of ,If anyone knows his name.
I will be well exited if we do sign Fein, He was very impressive in the world cup

Phil Cantilon?

ponner wrote:

Phil Cantilon?

Thats the fella, cheers mate.

Think we should sign Moore at all costs if he is available, Lets not forget he is a young kid too with plenty of years Rugby left in him.

Helen wrote:

Watching Moore on Friday was like waching Cunningham. He was, to me, extremely impressive.

Mind you, I also like the look of Lunt. He impressed me more than Moore at the start of the season.

Faiumu's lack of game-time has meant that he has yet to show us his best.

Just for the record - and to put matters right - this was me. Some other person must have hijacked my laptop just because I was mending hers!!