Hemmingway

Subject: Re: Hemmingway Wed Jul 09, 2008 7:53 am

ponner wrote:

BO JANGLES wrote:: I hope we never see the likes of him again, and i wouldn't mind betting there's a few players that feel the same way.

Talking to an ex player at weekend who said Sharp should have gone ages ago.

Totally agree with that Very Happy

Subject: Re: Hemmingway Wed Jul 09, 2008 4:40 pm

Just hope he is included in squad for Leeds game. i would personally have him in the starting 13.

Subject: Re: Hemmingway Wed Jul 09, 2008 6:15 pm

He's in the 19 but personally i'd use him as 18th man Wink

Subject: Re: Hemmingway Wed Jul 09, 2008 7:46 pm

ponner wrote:: He's in the 19 but personally i'd use him as 18th man

just as long as robinson is 19th man Very Happy

Subject: Re: Hemmingway Wed Jul 09, 2008 7:48 pm

I am wondering if Robinson can play with a team or is it just 1 man stuff?
no dis respect to him, maybe time will tell who knows.

Subject: Re: Hemmingway Wed Jul 09, 2008 7:51 pm

Mandy Giants Fan wrote:: I am wondering if Robinson can play with a team or is it just 1 man stuff?
no dis respect to him, maybe time will tell who knows.

time has tolled,he is not a team player.

Subject: Re: Hemmingway Wed Jul 09, 2008 7:54 pm

bostock wrote:

Mandy Giants Fan wrote:: I am wondering if Robinson can play with a team or is it just 1 man stuff?
no dis respect to him, maybe time will tell who knows.

time has tolled,he is not a team player.

I was never overly excited about Robinson's signature. He never made it at Wigan and only looked class at Salford for that one season, other than that we was just an average player.

If we are to persist with Brown at stand-off then we need a flare player at scrum half and Thorman has more of that than Robinson. However I still think Thorman and Robinson could be our best half back partnership.

Subject: Re: Hemmingway Wed Jul 09, 2008 7:58 pm

matt01 wrote:

bostock wrote:

Mandy Giants Fan wrote:: I am wondering if Robinson can play with a team or is it just 1 man stuff?
no dis respect to him, maybe time will tell who knows.

time has tolled,he is not a team player.

I was never overly excited about Robinson's signature. He never made it at Wigan and only looked class at Salford for that one season, other than that we was just an average player.

If we are to persist with Brown at stand-off then we need a flare player at scrum half and Thorman has more of that than Robinson. However I still think Thorman and Robinson could be our best half back partnership.

it was dunaman that made him look good at salford,when he left they went down hill fast.

Subject: Re: Hemmingway Wed Jul 09, 2008 8:01 pm

bostock wrote:

matt01 wrote:

bostock wrote:

Mandy Giants Fan wrote:: I am wondering if Robinson can play with a team or is it just 1 man stuff?
no dis respect to him, maybe time will tell who knows.

time has tolled,he is not a team player.

I was never overly excited about Robinson's signature. He never made it at Wigan and only looked class at Salford for that one season, other than that we was just an average player.

If we are to persist with Brown at stand-off then we need a flare player at scrum half and Thorman has more of that than Robinson. However I still think Thorman and Robinson could be our best half back partnership.

it was dunaman that made him look good at salford,we he left they went down hill fast.

Of course Dunaman was fantastic. A bit of a Costin really.

Subject: Re: Hemmingway Wed Jul 09, 2008 8:15 pm

Well said Matt.
Robinson will never be a Brad Drew.

Subject: Re: Hemmingway Wed Jul 09, 2008 8:23 pm

that is what we need next year,a dunaman,costin,drew some body with the craft! Very Happy

Subject: Re: Hemmingway Wed Jul 09, 2008 8:42 pm

Subject: Re: Hemmingway Wed Jul 09, 2008 9:30 pm

matt01 wrote:

bostock wrote:

Mandy Giants Fan wrote:: I am wondering if Robinson can play with a team or is it just 1 man stuff?
no dis respect to him, maybe time will tell who knows.

time has tolled,he is not a team player.

I was never overly excited about Robinson's signature. He never made it at Wigan and only looked class at Salford for that one season, other than that we was just an average player.

If we are to persist with Brown at stand-off then we need a flare player at scrum half and Thorman has more of that than Robinson. However I still think Thorman and Robinson could be our best half back partnership.

I agree with that Matt, and i would definitly play Brown in the centre, he has bulked up a fair bit , and i would be trying to get him into more of a Senior type player.

Subject: Re: Hemmingway Wed Jul 09, 2008 9:47 pm

WE NEED A PLAYMAKER IN PLAIN AND SIMPLE TERMS.
IF WE GET TWO, THEN THAT WOULD BE SUPER, WOULDN'T IT? Laughing

Subject: Re: Hemmingway Wed Jul 09, 2008 9:49 pm

Half back combinations need a run for a few games up to the end of the season, trouble is we have too many options.
Thorman/Robinson
Thorman/Hemingway
Thorman/Brown
Robinson/Hemingway
Robinson/Brown
Hemingway/Brown
But stick with the combination from the Bradford game against Leeds and see what happens, if still ok keep them for the next game.

Subject: Re: Hemmingway Wed Jul 09, 2008 9:58 pm

Not Brown........PLEASE Evil or Very Mad

Subject: Re: Hemmingway Wed Jul 09, 2008 10:00 pm

I wonder if Featherstone are looking for a future England/GB half back pairing?

Brown's position is centre - but a centre who can't run????

Subject: Re: Hemmingway Wed Jul 09, 2008 10:02 pm

reidy@work wrote:: Not Brown........PLEASE

But with Whatawira and Lolesi as centres, where would Brown play, loose forward ?? and move Wild into second row.

Subject: Re: Hemmingway Wed Jul 09, 2008 10:16 pm

don't forget brown was good last year,the problem is robinson.

Subject: Re: Hemmingway Thu Jul 10, 2008 8:16 am

bostock wrote:: don't forget brown was good last year,the problem is robinson.

drop him

Subject: Re: Hemmingway Fri Jul 11, 2008 8:05 am

bostock wrote:: don't forget brown was good last year,the problem is robinson.

When playing at centre. I didn't rate him at SO.